In 2026, whilst global aquaculture consumption continues to grow, the aquaculture sector faces the triple challenge of winter cold damage, disease risks and environmental management of effluent. An increasing number of aquaculture enterprises are turning their attention to the ‘land-based recirculating aquaculture system (RAS) combined with aquaponics’ model: the RAS maintains a stable water temperature of 27-29°C throughout the year, enabling the continuous year-round growth of catfish; the effluent from the farm, after being purified through biological filtration, is channelled into greenhouses for the cultivation of salad greens and leafy vegetables, transforming ‘wastewater’ into ‘fertile water’. A single water circuit produces two marketable products — this guide provides a detailed explanation of how catfish recirculating aquaculture systems combined with aquaponics can achieve high yields, antibiotic-free production and near-zero emissions.
Catfish (including the African catfish/leather-bearded catfish, Clarias gariepinus) are tolerant of low oxygen levels, grow rapidly and yield high production, making them one of the freshwater species with the greatest potential for industrialised farming. However, in traditional earthen ponds and open-water farming, farmers repeatedly face five key constraints:
1. Winter cold damage: Catfish are warm-water species, with an optimal water temperature of 25-32°C; they suffer frostbite and die at temperatures below 10°C. They cannot overwinter naturally in northern regions, whilst in the south they suffer severe weight loss during the winter months, limiting production to just one or two cycles per year;
2. Concentrated market supply and price collapse: With a concentrated harvest in autumn, purchase prices are driven down to their annual low, and farming profits are eroded by market cycles;
3. Disease and drug residues: Water quality deteriorates in high-density earthen ponds, leading to recurrent outbreaks of enteritis, gill rot and parasites. The heavy use of medication makes it difficult to pass drug residue tests for export and supermarket sales;
4. Muddy odour and quality: Silt-bottomed ponds readily accumulate geosmin, giving the fish flesh a muddy odour, which results in a decline in both processing yield and purchase price;
5. Effluent pollution: Under the ‘large-scale discharge and large-scale inflow’ model, aquaculture effluent is discharged directly, resulting in excessive nitrogen and phosphorus levels, making it increasingly difficult to obtain environmental impact assessments and water abstraction and discharge permits.
Land-based recirculating aquaculture transforms water from an ‘uncontrollable natural resource’ into a ‘controllable production factor’; combined with aquaponics to utilise nutrients from the effluent, these five constraints are overcome one by one.
The recirculating aquaculture system, coupled with a heat pump and an insulated facility, maintains the water temperature at a stable 27-29°C — the optimal growth range—throughout the year. Catfish grow continuously year-round, eliminating the need for ‘winter growth cessation and spring restocking’. Whereas traditional earthen ponds yield only one or two harvests per year, industrialised recirculating aquaculture enables multiple batches of rotational farming annually, ensuring a balanced supply throughout the year. Harvest timing can be scheduled according to processing orders, thereby avoiding the autumn price trough.
Catfish are naturally well-suited to recirculating aquaculture systems due to their tolerance of low oxygen levels and high stocking densities: the designed harvest density can reach 50-70 kg/m³. Combined with intelligent aeration (maintaining dissolved oxygen at 6 mg/L or above) and multi-stage filtration to continuously remove waste, survival rates in well-managed systems exceed 90%. Graded rearing and rational density management enable a significant increase in yield per unit of water volume.
Automatic feeders are linked to water quality sensors to maintain the feed conversion ratio (FCR) between 1.3 and 1.6. As feed accounts for approximately 60% of farming costs, every 0.1 improvement in the FCR translates into a tangible increase in profit. Data-driven management enables a quantifiable review of each farming cycle, making harvest sizes more predictable.
Multi-stage filtration combined with UV and ozone disinfection achieves a pathogen removal rate of over 99.9%, severing the transmission chain of pathogens entering via the inflow. As the enclosed facility does not exchange water with external water bodies — preventing the introduction of parasites via water and eliminating stress caused by sudden weather changes — the two most prevalent issues, enteritis and gill rot, become rare and manageable.
With reduced disease pressure, the use of medication consequently decreases. Recirculating aquaculture systems can significantly reduce or even eliminate the use of antibiotics, producing catfish that comply with EU and US drug residue standards. In export and supermarket channels, being antibiotic-free and traceable are key factors in securing premium pricing.
The clean water in recirculating aquaculture systems provides ideal conditions for ‘water-hanging’ to reduce body fat: by withholding feed and holding the fish for 7–10 days prior to market, odour-causing substances such as geosmin are effectively removed, resulting in firm flesh and the elimination of muddy odours. Combined with graded harvesting, this enables a stable supply of chilled whole fish and frozen catfish fillets, directly serving catering, retail and processing clients.
Recirculating aquaculture systems produce ‘biowater’ daily that is rich in ammonia nitrogen, nitrates and phosphorus—after being converted by biological filters, this becomes the ideal liquid fertiliser for vegetables. Aquaponics integrates this water into greenhouse hydroponic systems, achieving dual use of the same water for both fish farming and vegetable cultivation:
For every 100 kg of feed converted into biological water, the nitrogen requirements of approximately 1,200-2,000 square metres of hydroponic leafy vegetables can be met. The more feed introduced into the fish system, the greater the vegetable yield — a portion of the feed costs is ‘recovered’ by the vegetables, whilst effluent discharge approaches zero.
Deep Water Culture (DWC) hydroponics for fast-growing leafy vegetables such as lettuce, rocket, basil and spinach can achieve annual yields of 25-40 kg/m². Based on a project with an annual catfish production of 150 tonnes, the accompanying vegetable greenhouse can produce several hundred tonnes of salad vegetables, with particularly substantial price premiums in the fresh vegetable market during winter.
Vegetables grown through aquaponics require virtually no chemical fertilisers, and the risk of pesticide residues is close to zero, naturally aligning with supermarkets’ ‘green and traceable’ procurement standards. As fish and vegetables share the same water treatment and greenhouse infrastructure, investment and operational costs are lower than those of two independent systems.
Table 1: Detailed Comparison between Traditional Earthen Ponds and Catfish Recirculating Aquaculture Systems with Aquaponics
|
Parameters |
Traditional earthen pond aquaculture |
Catfish Recirculating Aquaculture System (RAS) combined with Aquaponics |
|
Water temperature |
Subject to seasonal fluctuations, risk of winter cold damage |
A steady 27-29°C all year round |
|
Dissolved oxygen |
High volatility, high risk of market saturation |
>6 mg/L (intelligent aeration/pure oxygen) |
|
Survival rate |
60%–75% |
>90% |
|
Stocking density |
Low density, reliant on large bodies of water |
50-70 kg/m³, rotational farming throughout the year |
|
Feed Conversion Ratio (FCR) |
1.5-2.0 |
1.3-1.6 |
|
Disease Control |
Transmitted via water; requires frequent medication |
Removal rate of over 99.9% (UV/ozone); can be used without antibiotics |
|
Water Use and Discharge |
Massive discharges and excessive inflows result in heavily polluted effluent |
Recirculation rate >95%; effluent is used for greenhouse vegetable cultivation, resulting in near-zero discharge |
|
Output structure |
A single fish product, launched simultaneously |
Fish and salad vegetables provide dual income streams, with a balanced supply throughout the year |
|
Flavours and Specifications |
A muddy, earthy smell; a mixture of large and small items |
Water is pumped in to remove the fishy odour, and the fish are sorted by size before being harvested to ensure uniformity. |
A well-designed facility can generate multiple sources of income:
1. Frozen catfish fillets: Skinned, boneless fillets supplied to export and supermarket channels, with consistent sizing and high yield;
2. Hang-dried, lean catfish: Chilled whole fish sold on the open market, with the muddy odour eliminated, commanding a significant premium;
3. Salad leaves and leafy greens: Year-round supply of lettuce, rocket, basil and other varieties, with substantial winter market premiums for fresh produce;
4. Fry and value-added processing: Reduced costs through in-house fry production, or integration with value-added sectors such as ready meals and pet food ingredients.
Q1: What water temperature do catfish require in a recirculating aquaculture system?
A: The optimal growth range is 27-29°C (suitable temperature range 25-32°C). A recirculating aquaculture system equipped with a heat pump and an insulated facility can maintain this range year-round, preventing cold damage and weight loss during winter and enabling multiple cultivation cycles throughout the year.
Q2: Do the vegetables grown in the aquaponics system affect fish yield?
A: No. The vegetables only consume ‘waste nitrogen’ — such as nitrate — that has been converted by biological filters; they do not compete with the fish for resources. On the contrary, the vegetables’ absorption of nitrogen and phosphorus stabilises water quality, reducing the need for water changes and waste discharge, thereby creating a mutually beneficial closed-loop system.
Q3: Does aquaponics require additional chemical fertiliser?
A: Generally not. More than 30% of the nitrogen and phosphorus in the feed is converted by microorganisms and absorbed by the vegetables; it is only necessary to supplement trace elements such as iron, potassium and calcium during high-yield periods.
Q4: Is recirculating aquaculture of catfish profitable?
A: Whilst the initial investment in RAS is relatively high, it ensures a balanced supply throughout the year (avoiding periods of low prices), a survival rate exceeding 90 per cent, an FCR of 1.3-1.6, antibiotic-free export certification, and a secondary income stream from aquaponics. By spreading the fixed asset investment across multiple annual harvests and dual revenue streams from fish and vegetables, the payback period for large-scale projects can be kept within a reasonable range.
Q5: What equipment is required for a catfish recirculating aquaculture system (RAS) combined with aquaponics?
A: Core modules: drum/disc filters, fluidised-bed biofilters, CO₂ removal towers, heat pumps/heating and cooling units, UV/ozone units, intelligent aeration systems, online sensors and central control cabinets, as well as the accompanying DWC hydroponic greenhouse and nutrient solution control system — it is recommended that these be designed as an integrated system.
From fry selection and facility design to adult fish rearing, fish fillet processing and integrated vegetable greenhouse facilities, Wolize provides one-stop RAS equipment and engineering services — including process design, equipment selection, installation and commissioning, and after-sales training. Please feel free to contact our team for a free layout assessment and target yield calculation.
Figure 1: Schematic diagram of recirculating aquaculture for catfish (Silurus asotus) and aquaponics